Seems that things change, but according to the FAQ, there are still some issues with this matter (know how much Space left and use it)
Il still think that mixing réplication (raid) and file system is a very bad idea.
@fink @daftaupe @martin
This break the "layer" model. i have 3 layer : raid, volume management, and fs (Can Swap the two first). If one of them is upgraded or replace by another, no problem. This also respect the unix philosophy : do a single thing, but do it well. Computing had always used layer model (network...). Because it's good and reliable. And for me, keeping my data safe is the most important thing.
@hoper @fink @martin Talking about data safety I wonder why Synology is recommending btrfs (they probably want to take the risk of putting their customers data in danger), https://www.synology.com/en-us/dsm/Btrfs. I think you might be interested about the paragraph related to data corruption. By the way which fs are you using that provides the same features ?
@daftaupe @fink @martin
Just checked this link, thanks.
Metadata miroring is a FS feature. For exemple ext4 make many copy of the superbloc. Guess that one day ext(5?) will offer more. In fact, I don't feel the need to have multiple copy of metadata because :
hardware problems (badblock) can't be an issue anymore with raidX
Logical problem (silent corruption) is also an issue already solved by mdadm with raid6. (callded "self healing" on synology link)
For last feature, snapshots >LVM.
By the way, talking about links, what about his one ?
"The parity RAID code has multiple serious data-loss bugs in it. It should not be used for anything other than testing purposes."
Or this one :
Saying that very serious bug about raid have been corrected in linux 4.16. (Sorry, I'm still using a 4.9 kernel, and I think this is not so old...)
It's good to see people making news things, and other in a hurry to test it...
Me ? I will wait :)
Le réseau social de l'avenir : Pas d'annonces, pas de surveillance institutionnelle, conception éthique et décentralisation ! Possédez vos données avec Mastodon !