TIL that #Rust, while amazing, isn't so amazing for quick-and-dirty coding. It's like flying the Concorde for a 1-hour car trip.

@JonYoder There are reasons I often reach for the shell for quick-and-dirty things. But for anything serious, it quickly becomes a problem. In the days of Python 2, it was a good replacement, but with Python 3's inability to correctly handle POSIX filenames, environment variables, and parameters, I wouldn't bother. Rust is actually pretty decent for a lot of quick stuff once you get used to it.

@jgoerzen What kinds of problems have you run into with Python 3?

@JonYoder I wrote a series of articles on this subject culminating in changelog.complete.org/archive . In short, I was so burned by my effort to port #pygopherd to #Python 3 -- and the utter crappiness and inconsistency of handling non-UTF8 in even the library bundled with Python -- that I consider it unsuitable for any purpose involving filenames, command-line parameters, or environment variables. One lovely tidbit is the zipfile.py tries to decode non-UTF8 sequences as cp437 in ALL cases!

@JonYoder If you want a coffee with your reading, after that first link, you can check out changelog.complete.org/archive and changelog.complete.org/archive . The upshot of it is, as far as I can tell, it is impossible to write cross-platform #Python code that handles filenames correctly on both POSIX and Windows. #Rust gets this right, and Python's attempt to assume the whole world has used #Unicode since the beginning of time is a real pain.

@JonYoder You got me thinking in more detail why I reflexively avoid #Python now, despite the fact that I wrote two large programs (#OfflineIMAP and #pygopherd) in it, and published a book about it. 1/

@JonYoder It is astonishing to me that #Python still has a Global Interpreter Lock in 2022. wiki.python.org/moin/GlobalInt Multithreading in Python is mostly a fiction. There are kludges like docs.python.org/3/library/mult which use fork, pipes, pickling, and message passing to simulate threads. But there are so many dragons down that path -- performance and platform-specific ones (different things can be pickled on Windows vs. Linux) that it is a poor substitute. 3/

@JonYoder Sure, people use #Python for things like #AI work. In this case, Python is merely a shell; the real multithreaded code is in a different language (often C). The way to get performant multithreading out of Python is to not use Python at all. 4/

@JonYoder When I started using #Python more than 20 years ago now, it was an attractive alternative to Perl: like Perl, you don't have to worry about memory management as with C, but Python code was more maintainable. By now, though, even writing a Unix-style cat command in Python is extraordinarily complicated lucumr.pocoo.org/2014/5/12/eve . All the "foo-like objects" are an interesting abstraction until they break horribly, and the lack of strong types makes it hard to scale code size. 5/

@JonYoder These days, we have credible alternatives to #Python: #Rust, #Go, and #Haskell (among many others). All three of these are performant, avoid all the manual legwork of #C or the boilerplate of #Java, and provide easy ways to do simple things. 6/

@JonYoder The one place I still see #Python being used is situations where the #REPL is valuable. (Note, #Haskell also has this). #Jupyter is an example of this too. People use #Python for rapid testing of things and interactive prototyping. For a time, when I had date arithmetic problems, I'd open up the Python CLI and write stuff there. Nowadays it's simpler to just write a Rust program to do it for me, really. 7/

@JonYoder So that leaves me thinking: We're thinking about #Python wrong these days. Its greatest utility is as a shell, not a language to write large programs in. As a shell, it is decent, especially for scientific work. Like other shells, most of the serious work is farmed out to code not written in Python, but there is utility in having it as a shell anyhow. And like a shell, once your requirements get to a certain point, you reach for something more serious. end/

@jgoerzen @JonYoder fascinating stuff, thanks for sharing this insight. You mentioned Haskell, I was wondering if you had much experience with Lisp dialects such as CL or Clojure? I imagine Clojure may have similar concerns as Java. CL is as old as the hills but it has my curiosity

@trevdev @JonYoder I used CL some back in college, and dabble in elisp from time to time, but I'm not expert in either. I found Haskell particularly fascinating as I think it takes the FP paradigm further than even those do (via laziness and segmented side-effects). But Lisps could also serve the REPL need. Maybe someone else would know more (#Scheme is in this universe too, but I'm not fluent in it)

@trevdev @jgoerzen @JonYoder

I'm into it mostly to train my brain on something that is not inspired by C. I discovered the Lambda Calculus and that made the exercise even more interesting.

I really like the syntax, it's so simple that other languages seem complicated to read for me now haha
Can feel weird at first but you get used to it : everything is expression (no statement), parentheses is the single expression delimiter, …


@trevdev @jgoerzen @JonYoder

But you can taste Scheme without parens, because Scheme lets you to tweak it if you want, it's still Scheme (draketo.de/software/wisp 👋 @ArneBab)

I don't leverage the REPL very far but I do use it pretty often.
Imagine a Python program running a Python REPL you can use to load new code to modify/extend the behavior of the Python program while it's running (more powerful than hot reload, gnu.org/software/guile/manual/ 👋 @dthompson )

· · Web · 1 · 1 · 1

@jeko @trevdev @jgoerzen @JonYoder @dthompson If you want to see how short solutions look in #wisp, have a look at the advent of wisp code 2021: draketo.de/software/advent-of- — I solved the first 12 tasks of the advent of code there, with code from elegant to "I will replace the pilot by a simple bash script" :-)

The code is always doubled—look at the required change.

If you want to have a list of awesome things about Guile, have a look at the 10 ways GNU Guile is 10x better: draketo.de/software/guile-10x

Inscrivez-vous pour prendre part à la conversation

Le réseau social de l'avenir : pas de publicité, pas de surveillance institutionnelle, conception éthique et décentralisation ! Gardez le contrôle de vos données avec Mastodon !